Spring Framework Tutorial

Software Setup and Configuration (STS/Eclipse/IntelliJ)

Core Spring

Spring Annotations

Spring Data

Spring JDBC

Spring Security

Circular Dependencies in Spring

Circular dependencies occur in Spring when two or more beans depend on each other, either directly or indirectly. Such a situation can lead to issues during the bean creation process.

Let's take a simple example:

  • BeanA depends on BeanB.
  • BeanB depends on BeanA.

In this scenario, when the Spring container tries to create an instance of BeanA, it sees that BeanA needs an instance of BeanB. So, it pauses the creation of BeanA and starts to create BeanB. But then, while creating BeanB, it realizes that BeanB needs an instance of BeanA, leading to a cyclic dependency problem.

How Spring Handles Circular Dependencies:

  1. Setter Injection: The Spring Framework resolves circular dependencies through setter injection. When a circular dependency is detected while using setter injection, the Spring container creates a new bean instance (without setting the dependent beans) and then later on, the dependencies are set using the setter methods.

  2. Constructor Injection: Circular dependencies through constructor injection will cause the container to throw a BeanCurrentlyInCreationException. It's generally not possible for the Spring container to resolve circular dependencies when constructor injection is used because the constructor has to be fully satisfied before the bean is constructed.

  3. @Lazy Annotation: If you are using constructor injection, and you know of a circular dependency, you can use the @Lazy annotation. This tells Spring to create a proxy object as a placeholder for the real object and inject the proxy. This way, the actual initialization of the bean can be deferred until it's first accessed.

Best Practices to Avoid Circular Dependencies:

  1. Revisit Design: Circular dependencies are often a sign of a tight coupling between beans or components. It might be beneficial to revisit the design and see if the responsibilities of the involved classes can be adjusted.

  2. Use Service Layer: Group related operations in service beans. For example, operations related to user management (like adding, deleting, updating users) can be placed under a UserService class. This way, other beans or services can depend on UserService rather than individual operations.

  3. Component Splitting: Sometimes, splitting a bean into multiple smaller beans can help in resolving circular dependencies.

  4. Aware of Constructor Injection: Be cautious while using constructor injection. If there's a chance for circular references, consider using setter injection or field injection.

Remember that while Spring can handle circular dependencies to some extent, it's generally a good idea to design your application in such a way that you avoid them in the first place. Circular dependencies can make the code harder to understand, test, and maintain.

  1. Handling Circular Dependencies in Spring:

    • Description: Spring provides mechanisms to handle circular dependencies, such as using @Lazy annotation or switching from constructor injection to setter injection.
    • Code:
      @Component
      public class A {
          @Autowired
          private B b;
          // ...
      }
      
      @Component
      public class B {
          @Autowired
          private A a;
          // ...
      }
      
  2. Setter Injection and Circular Dependencies in Spring Beans:

    • Description: Using setter injection instead of constructor injection can help in breaking circular dependencies, as beans can be partially initialized and then dependencies set later.
    • Code:
      @Component
      public class A {
          private B b;
      
          @Autowired
          public void setB(B b) {
              this.b = b;
          }
          // ...
      }