Spring Framework Tutorial
Software Setup and Configuration (STS/Eclipse/IntelliJ)
Core Spring
Spring Annotations
Spring Data
Spring JDBC
Spring Security
Circular dependencies occur in Spring when two or more beans depend on each other, either directly or indirectly. Such a situation can lead to issues during the bean creation process.
Let's take a simple example:
BeanA
depends on BeanB
.BeanB
depends on BeanA
.In this scenario, when the Spring container tries to create an instance of BeanA
, it sees that BeanA
needs an instance of BeanB
. So, it pauses the creation of BeanA
and starts to create BeanB
. But then, while creating BeanB
, it realizes that BeanB
needs an instance of BeanA
, leading to a cyclic dependency problem.
Setter Injection: The Spring Framework resolves circular dependencies through setter injection. When a circular dependency is detected while using setter injection, the Spring container creates a new bean instance (without setting the dependent beans) and then later on, the dependencies are set using the setter methods.
Constructor Injection: Circular dependencies through constructor injection will cause the container to throw a BeanCurrentlyInCreationException
. It's generally not possible for the Spring container to resolve circular dependencies when constructor injection is used because the constructor has to be fully satisfied before the bean is constructed.
@Lazy Annotation: If you are using constructor injection, and you know of a circular dependency, you can use the @Lazy
annotation. This tells Spring to create a proxy object as a placeholder for the real object and inject the proxy. This way, the actual initialization of the bean can be deferred until it's first accessed.
Revisit Design: Circular dependencies are often a sign of a tight coupling between beans or components. It might be beneficial to revisit the design and see if the responsibilities of the involved classes can be adjusted.
Use Service Layer: Group related operations in service beans. For example, operations related to user management (like adding, deleting, updating users) can be placed under a UserService
class. This way, other beans or services can depend on UserService
rather than individual operations.
Component Splitting: Sometimes, splitting a bean into multiple smaller beans can help in resolving circular dependencies.
Aware of Constructor Injection: Be cautious while using constructor injection. If there's a chance for circular references, consider using setter injection or field injection.
Remember that while Spring can handle circular dependencies to some extent, it's generally a good idea to design your application in such a way that you avoid them in the first place. Circular dependencies can make the code harder to understand, test, and maintain.
Handling Circular Dependencies in Spring:
@Lazy
annotation or switching from constructor injection to setter injection.@Component public class A { @Autowired private B b; // ... } @Component public class B { @Autowired private A a; // ... }
Setter Injection and Circular Dependencies in Spring Beans:
@Component public class A { private B b; @Autowired public void setB(B b) { this.b = b; } // ... }